Shortstop Is INSANE in 2026: The Top 10 Rankings That Will Start Arguments Immediately
- Young Horn
- 1 day ago
- 3 min read
Shortstop used to be where teams hid their best defender and prayed he could hit .260.
Now?
It’s basically the NBA point guard position of baseball — you either have a superstar… or you’re actively googling “top shortstop prospects 2027.”
Shortstop is now the deepest position in baseball by far, with power, speed, defense, and MVP candidates everywhere you look .
So let’s break down the real Top 10 shortstops heading into 2026, using projections, actual performance, and a little common sense (rare in March).
1. Bobby Witt Jr. (Royals)
Projected 2026: .288 / .344 / .512, 25+ HR, 35+ SB, ~6.5–7 WAR
This one is not up for debate.
Witt is the definition of a five-tool monster:
elite defense
power
speed
durability
and the confidence of a guy who knows he’s him
If his “down year” is still elite, you’re dealing with a unicorn.
Translation: best shortstop in baseball, and it’s not particularly close. If it weren't for Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani, Witt would be the best player in baseball.
2. Corey Seager (Rangers)
Projected 2026: .285 / .360 / .520, 30 HR, ~5 WAR
Seager is what happens when a shortstop decides defense is optional and hitting baseballs very hard is not.
Elite bat
Consistent power
Postseason DNA
If you want offense at SS, this is your guy.
3. Francisco Lindor (Mets)
Projected 2026: .270 / .340 / .480, 25 HR, 20 SB, ~5 WAR
Lindor is still the most complete “veteran star” at the position.
switch hitter
elite glove
leadership guy
He may not be the flashiest anymore, but he’s still: ridiculously reliable. He will be frowning all year long!
4. Gunnar Henderson (Orioles)
Projected 2026: .275 / .350 / .500, 30 HR
Technically moves around the infield, but when he’s at short: absolute problem
big power
improving defense
still ascending
This feels like a future #1 if everything clicks.
5. Mookie Betts (Dodgers)
Projected 2026: .290 / .380 / .500
Yes… still weird.
But also: still elite
Betts playing shortstop is like putting a Ferrari engine in a pickup truck.
Does it make sense? Not really. Does it still work? Absolutely.
6. Geraldo Perdomo (Diamondbacks)
Projected 2026: .280 / .360 / .450, ~5–6 WAR
This is where casual fans go:“Wait… him??”
Yes. Him.
Perdomo just put up a 7 WAR season and has quietly become:
elite defensively
extremely disciplined at the plate
a winning baseball player
Not flashy, just insanely effective
7. Trea Turner (Phillies)
Projected 2026: .285 / .340 / .470, 25+ SB
Still one of the fastest players in baseball.
hits for average
steals bags
gets hot in bunches
He’s basically: chaos in cleats
8. Elly De La Cruz (Reds)
Projected 2026: .255 / .330 / .480, 25 HR, 40 SB
The most entertaining player on this list.
absurd tools
insane speed
highlight machine
Downside: sometimes swings like he’s trying to hit a golf ball to Jupiter
Upside: Top 3 MVP Finish
9. Jeremy Peña (Astros)
Projected 2026: .265 / .320 / .430
Peña is the classic: “you appreciate him more if he’s on your team” guy
strong defense
solid bat
postseason credibility
Not flashy, but always in the right place.
10. Ezequiel Tovar (Rockies)
Projected 2026: .260 / .310 / .450, 20+ HR
One of the best defensive shortstops in baseball.
Gold Glove caliber
improving power
still only mid-20s
If the bat takes another step, he’s jumping this list fast
Sleepers Who Could Crash This List
🔥 Masyn Winn (Cardinals)
elite arm
developing bat
⚡ Zach Neto (Angels)
sneaky pop + defense
Top prospects wave incoming
Shortstop is LOADED with young talent — MLB literally has a pipeline of SS prospects waiting to take jobs
Translation: this list will age terribly (as it should)
Shortstop in 2026 is ridiculous.
You’ve got MVP candidates
You’ve got 30/30 guys
You’ve got Gold Glove defenders who also hit
And the craziest part?
This might still be the beginning of the golden era
If your team doesn’t have a shortstop right now…you’re either rebuilding or lying to yourself, or the Yankees.
Comments